Crash of 1929: Difference between revisions
imported>Nick Gardner No edit summary |
mNo edit summary |
||
| (5 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{subpages}}{{TOC|Right}} | {{subpages}}{{TOC|Right}} | ||
The sharp fall in the share prices quoted on the [[New York Stock Exchange]], that came to be known as the '''crash of 1929''', started shortly after the downturn in economic activity known as the [[Great Depression]] and is believed to have contributed to its severity. The | The sharp fall in the share prices quoted on the [[New York Stock Exchange]], that came to be known as the '''crash of 1929''', started shortly after the downturn in economic activity known as the [[Great Depression]] and is believed to have contributed to its severity. The decline in prices continued until the beginning of the recovery in economic activity in 1933, by which time average prices had shrunk to no more than 15 per cent of their 1929 peak values. | ||
The once popular view that categorised the crash as the bursting of a speculative [[Asset price bubble|bubble]] has since been replaced by a consensus among economists that it was the consequence of mistaken [[Monetary policy|monetary policies]]. | The once popular view that categorised the crash as the bursting of a speculative [[Asset price bubble|bubble]] has since been replaced by a consensus among economists that it was the consequence of mistaken [[Monetary policy|monetary policies]]. | ||
| Line 12: | Line 12: | ||
<ref name=Galbraith>John Kenneth Galbraith: ''The Great Crash 1929'', Penguin Books 1992 </ref>, who referred to it as " the typhoon that blew out of lower Manhattan in October 1929". The savings of a great number of people were wiped out, the reputations of some eminent authorities were damaged <ref> Including Professor Irving Fisher, who was henceforth best known for his 1929 advice that "Stock prices have reached what looks like a permanently high plateau".</ref> and there were a few well-publicised suicides | <ref name=Galbraith>John Kenneth Galbraith: ''The Great Crash 1929'', Penguin Books 1992 </ref>, who referred to it as " the typhoon that blew out of lower Manhattan in October 1929". The savings of a great number of people were wiped out, the reputations of some eminent authorities were damaged <ref> Including Professor Irving Fisher, who was henceforth best known for his 1929 advice that "Stock prices have reached what looks like a permanently high plateau".</ref> and there were a few well-publicised suicides | ||
What followed in the ensuing years was the result of mutual interactions between the behaviour of investors on the stock exchange and the economic downturn; and its eventual outcome was the loss by 1933 of about 90 per cent of the former value of United States equities <ref> For more detail about the sequence of events, see the [[/timelines|Timelines subpage]]</ref>. | What followed in the ensuing years was the result of mutual interactions between the behaviour of investors on the stock exchange and the economic downturn; and its eventual outcome was the loss by 1933 of about 90 per cent of the former value of United States [[Equity (finance)|equities]] <ref> For more detail about the sequence of events, see the [[/timelines|Timelines subpage]]</ref>. | ||
==Explanations== | ==Explanations== | ||
It is generally agreed that most investors would not have been alarmed by the downturn in industrial activity that had preceded the initial crash, but that awareness of the more severe downturn in subsequent years must have contributed to the continuing fall in prices. What is not generally agreed upon is the cause of the initial crash. The conventional explanation has, for many years, been that it was caused by the bursting of a speculative bubble, implying that stocks were priced above their real value in 1929 <ref name=Galbraith/><ref> see the summary of Galbraith's analysis on the [[/Tutorials|Tutorials subpage]]</ref>. Evidence to the contrary has since emerged <ref> Ellen McGrattan: ''The Stock Market Crash of 1929: Irving Fisher Was Right!'', Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, Research Department Staff Report 294, December 2001[[http://www.bportugal.pt/events/conferences/CME/mppaper.pdf]]</ref>, and Federal Reserve Board Chairman (and author of scholarly works on the period) Ben Bernanke has endorsed the conclusion that the crash was not the consequence of speculation <ref name=Bernanke> Ben Bernanke: ''Asset-Price "Bubbles" and Monetary Policy'', speech at the New York Chapter of the National Association for Business Economics, October 15, 2002[http://www.federalreserve.gov/boarddocs/speeches/2002/20021015/default.htm]</ref>. Most economists now accept Milton Friedman's contention that the crash was caused by the perverse application of monetary policy by the Federal Reserve Board | It is generally agreed that most investors would not have been alarmed by the downturn in industrial activity that had preceded the initial crash, but that awareness of the more severe downturn in subsequent years must have contributed to the continuing fall in stock exchange prices. What is not generally agreed upon is the cause of the initial crash. The conventional explanation has, for many years, been that it was caused by the bursting of a speculative bubble, implying that stocks were priced above their real value in 1929 <ref name=Galbraith/><ref> see the summary of Galbraith's analysis on the [[/Tutorials|Tutorials subpage]]</ref>. Evidence to the contrary has since emerged <ref> Ellen McGrattan: ''The Stock Market Crash of 1929: Irving Fisher Was Right!'', Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, Research Department Staff Report 294, December 2001[[http://www.bportugal.pt/events/conferences/CME/mppaper.pdf]]</ref>, and Federal Reserve Board Chairman (and author of scholarly works on the period) Ben Bernanke has endorsed the conclusion that the crash was not the consequence of speculation <ref name=Bernanke> Ben Bernanke: ''Asset-Price "Bubbles" and Monetary Policy'', speech at the New York Chapter of the National Association for Business Economics, October 15, 2002[http://www.federalreserve.gov/boarddocs/speeches/2002/20021015/default.htm]</ref>. Most economists now accept Milton Friedman's contention that the crash was caused by the perverse application of monetary policy by the Federal Reserve Board | ||
<ref name=Friedman> Milton Friedman and Anna Schwartz ''A Monetary History of the United States 1867-1960'', Princeton University Press for NBER, 1963</ref> <ref> see the summary of Friedman's analysis on the [[/Tutorials|Tutorials subpage]]</ref>. | <ref name=Friedman> Milton Friedman and Anna Schwartz ''A Monetary History of the United States 1867-1960'', Princeton University Press for NBER, 1963</ref> <ref> see the summary of Friedman's analysis on the [[/Tutorials|Tutorials subpage]]</ref>. | ||
==Consequences== | ==Consequences== | ||
Despite the evidence concerning the sequence of events some commentators are still incline to the view that the crash of 1929 caused the [[Great Depression]]. That was not the view taken by John Kenneth Galbraith, but he did say that "had the economy been fundamentally sound, the effect of the great stock market crash might have been small" <ref name=Galbraith/>, a remark that implies that he considered it to have made a major contribution | Despite the evidence concerning the sequence of events some commentators are still incline to the view that the crash of 1929 caused the [[Great Depression]]. That was not the view taken by John Kenneth Galbraith, but he did say that "had the economy been fundamentally sound, the effect of the great stock market crash might have been small" <ref name=Galbraith/>, a remark that implies that he considered it to have made a major contribution. The discussion of the factors contributing to that depression in the article on that subject throws further light on that assessment. | ||
==Remedies== | ==Remedies== | ||
==References== | ==References== | ||
<references/> | <references/>[[Category:Suggestion Bot Tag]] | ||
Latest revision as of 16:00, 2 August 2024
The sharp fall in the share prices quoted on the New York Stock Exchange, that came to be known as the crash of 1929, started shortly after the downturn in economic activity known as the Great Depression and is believed to have contributed to its severity. The decline in prices continued until the beginning of the recovery in economic activity in 1933, by which time average prices had shrunk to no more than 15 per cent of their 1929 peak values.
The once popular view that categorised the crash as the bursting of a speculative bubble has since been replaced by a consensus among economists that it was the consequence of mistaken monetary policies.
The stock exchange crash
The crash marked the end of a period of eight increasingly prosperous years, known as the "roaring twenties": a period of above-average growth of national income, exceptionally rapid growth in corporate earnings, and even more rapid growth in stock exchange prices. That trend intensified in the latter years, with stock prices rising from about 10 times corporate earnings in 1928 to 15 times or more in 1929. Then, in the June of 1929, industrial activity began a decline [1] that continued throughout the rest of the year, and, in a few days in the autumn of 1929, the average share price on the New York stock exchange dropped by a staggering 30 per cent.
There have been many day-by-day accounts of that dramatic occurrence, notably that of John Kenneth Galbraith [2], who referred to it as " the typhoon that blew out of lower Manhattan in October 1929". The savings of a great number of people were wiped out, the reputations of some eminent authorities were damaged [3] and there were a few well-publicised suicides
What followed in the ensuing years was the result of mutual interactions between the behaviour of investors on the stock exchange and the economic downturn; and its eventual outcome was the loss by 1933 of about 90 per cent of the former value of United States equities [4].
Explanations
It is generally agreed that most investors would not have been alarmed by the downturn in industrial activity that had preceded the initial crash, but that awareness of the more severe downturn in subsequent years must have contributed to the continuing fall in stock exchange prices. What is not generally agreed upon is the cause of the initial crash. The conventional explanation has, for many years, been that it was caused by the bursting of a speculative bubble, implying that stocks were priced above their real value in 1929 [2][5]. Evidence to the contrary has since emerged [6], and Federal Reserve Board Chairman (and author of scholarly works on the period) Ben Bernanke has endorsed the conclusion that the crash was not the consequence of speculation [7]. Most economists now accept Milton Friedman's contention that the crash was caused by the perverse application of monetary policy by the Federal Reserve Board [8] [9].
Consequences
Despite the evidence concerning the sequence of events some commentators are still incline to the view that the crash of 1929 caused the Great Depression. That was not the view taken by John Kenneth Galbraith, but he did say that "had the economy been fundamentally sound, the effect of the great stock market crash might have been small" [2], a remark that implies that he considered it to have made a major contribution. The discussion of the factors contributing to that depression in the article on that subject throws further light on that assessment.
Remedies
References
- ↑ Geoffrey Moore and Julius Sishkin Indicators of Business Contractions and Expansions page 25 National Bureau of Economic Research Occasional Paper 103, 1967 [1]
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 John Kenneth Galbraith: The Great Crash 1929, Penguin Books 1992
- ↑ Including Professor Irving Fisher, who was henceforth best known for his 1929 advice that "Stock prices have reached what looks like a permanently high plateau".
- ↑ For more detail about the sequence of events, see the Timelines subpage
- ↑ see the summary of Galbraith's analysis on the Tutorials subpage
- ↑ Ellen McGrattan: The Stock Market Crash of 1929: Irving Fisher Was Right!, Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, Research Department Staff Report 294, December 2001[[2]]
- ↑ Ben Bernanke: Asset-Price "Bubbles" and Monetary Policy, speech at the New York Chapter of the National Association for Business Economics, October 15, 2002[3]
- ↑ Milton Friedman and Anna Schwartz A Monetary History of the United States 1867-1960, Princeton University Press for NBER, 1963
- ↑ see the summary of Friedman's analysis on the Tutorials subpage