CZ:Ready for reading: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Pat Palmer
mNo edit summary
m (Text replacement - "Neighborhood (Social Science)" to "Neighborhood (social science)")
 
(49 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:




Below are articles which have been nominated as '''ready for reading'''.  These may be featured on the landing page or in advertisements for new members.  
Below are articles which have been nominated as '''ready for reading'''.  These may be [[CZ:Featured article|featured]] on the landing page or in advertisements for new members.  


We particularly want examples of articles that are  different from what one would expect to find on Wikipedia in some important way.  Communal editing by the larger crew of authors in Wikipedia can often end up degrading a good article, because while it may result in an increase in accuracy details, it may disrupt the voice and global structure of the article, as well as its clarity and focus on fundamentals.  It's the difference, for example, between a chapter in a textbook that will delight a student trying to learn a difficult subject, and the usual pile of overwhelming detail.  In this respect, the Citizendium's smaller pool of active authors makes for a more productive writing environment than is possible in a larger wiki.
We particularly want examples of articles that are  different from what one would expect to find on Wikipedia in some important way.  Communal editing by the larger crew of authors in Wikipedia can often end up degrading a good article, because while it may result in an increase in accuracy details, it may disrupt the voice and global structure of the article, as well as its clarity and focus on fundamentals.  It's the difference, for example, between a chapter in a textbook that will delight a student trying to learn a difficult subject, and the usual pile of overwhelming detail.  In this respect, the Citizendium's smaller pool of active authors makes for a more productive writing environment than is possible in a larger wiki.


Citizendium has a lot of good science articles which do not yet appear in this list.  This may be because they need updating, having been written originally a decade ago when Citizendium had a larger membership. The ones we like best have very consciously avoided the errors present in the Wikipedia versions, whereas the Wikipedia versions (even if chock full of more details) still have the same errors and more.  
Many of these articles have been ported already to Wikipedia, where they can enjoy a wider exposure and are guaranteed to persist longer.  However, in some cases, the Wikipedia versions have since been extensively modified, and not always in ways that improve the article.


Several members of the Advisory group (as of August 2020) like the idea of having multiple articles by different authors on the same topic.  In some cases, they challenge people to better their own self-nominated articles below.
Several members of the Advisory group (as of August 2020) like the idea of having multiple articles by different authors on the same topic.  In some cases, they challenge people to better their own self-nominated articles below.
We don't necessarily consider the following articles polished, perfect or complete, but we believe that their existence is a valuable addition to articles about the same topics in other online encyclopedias.


__TOC__
__TOC__
Line 15: Line 17:
To nominate an article, please add it ''in alphabetical order'' to one of the two lists below.  Using the list format we've begun here, please add it to the appropriate list, including sublist items for who the lead author was (if known), who is making the nomination, and any comments helping to explain its value.
To nominate an article, please add it ''in alphabetical order'' to one of the two lists below.  Using the list format we've begun here, please add it to the appropriate list, including sublist items for who the lead author was (if known), who is making the nomination, and any comments helping to explain its value.


== Nominated by non-leads ==
== List of articles nominated by non-leads ==


* [[Acid rain]]
** mostly the work of Milton Beychok back in 2010
** nominated by Pat Palmer
* [[American conservatism]]
* [[American conservatism]]
** nominated by Roger Lohmann, 8/13/2020
** nominated by Roger Lohmann, 8/13/2020
** largely written by Howard Berkowitz
** largely written by Howard Berkowitz
** also some related national security topics by HB – although controversial with some – really very, very good. Milton Boychek was also a very active contributor at about that same time.
** also some related national security topics by HB – although controversial with some – really very, very good. Milton Boychek was also a very active contributor at about that same time.
** submitted to Encyclosphere via ZWI Export on 3/23/2022 [[User:Pat Palmer|Pat Palmer]] ([[User talk:Pat Palmer|talk]]) 12:21, 24 March 2022 (CDT)
* [[Benchmark quantities]]
** largely written by Mark Widmer
** imaginative and absolutely unique; I haven't seen anything like it anywhere; and, it has some laughs buried in it
* [[Bottle]]
** nominated by Pat Palmer
** needs a few graphics/photos
** charming and sweet
** collaboratively written, with contribs from Ro, Larry, Gareth and Tom Morris
* [[Coal_mining]]
** written in part by [[User:Pat_Palmer]], as well as several others
** submitted to Encyclosphere via ZWI Export on 3/23/2022 [[User:Pat Palmer|Pat Palmer]] ([[User talk:Pat Palmer|talk]]) 12:32, 24 March 2022 (CDT)
* [[COVID-19]]
** largely written by Gareth Leng
** nominated by Pat Palmer
** neutral introduction and overview of the current pandemic
** submitted to Encyclosphere via ZWI Export on 3/23/2022 [[User:Pat Palmer|Pat Palmer]] ([[User talk:Pat Palmer|talk]]) 12:23, 24 March 2022 (CDT)
* [[Dark Peak]]
** largely written by [[User:Martin_Wyatt]]
** nominated by Pat Palmer
** far better (at present) than its WP counterpart
** submitted to Encyclosphere via ZWI Export on 3/23/2022 [[User:Pat Palmer|Pat Palmer]] ([[User talk:Pat Palmer|talk]]) 12:23, 24 March 2022 (CDT)
*[[Football to 1900]]
**nominated by Roger Lohmann
**largely written by John Leach
* [[Jane_Addams]] - American social worker, author, pacifist and feminist leader and Nobel Peace Prize laureate, the first American woman so honored
* [[Jane_Addams]] - American social worker, author, pacifist and feminist leader and Nobel Peace Prize laureate, the first American woman so honored
** nominated by Roger Lohmann, 8/13/2020
** nominated by Roger Lohmann, 8/13/2020
** largely written by Richard Jensen
** largely written by Richard Jensen
** Truly outstanding
** Truly outstanding; appears to have been ported to Wikipedia very recently
* [[Life]]
* [[Life]]
** nominated by Gareth Leng
** nominated by Gareth Leng
** lead author Anthony Sebastian
** lead author Anthony Sebastian
** This was Anthony’s tour-de-force; idiosyncratic in places, yet with a unity of tone and intent that is striking.
** This was Anthony’s tour-de-force; idiosyncratic in places, yet with a unity of tone and intent that is striking.
* [[Line]]
* [[Line (Euclidean geometry)]]
** nominated by Gareth Leng
** nominated by Gareth Leng
** did not compare to the WP version
** did not compare to the WP version
* [[Neighborhood]]
* [[One-way_encryption]], a.k.a. [[Password_encryption]]
** nominated by Pat Palmer (and mostly written by me)
** All this and much more in Wikipedia, but if you want to know how computers store and use passwords, this is what you need
* [[Neighborhood (social science)]]
** nominated by Gareth Leng
** nominated by Gareth Leng
** largely written by Roger Lohmann
** did not compare to the WP version
** did not compare to the WP version
* [[Scientific Method]]
** Featured Article on landing page, 8/28/2020
* [[Pali]], [[Pali Canon]] and [[Pali Text Society]]
** largely written by Peter Jackson
** nominated by Pat Palmer
** still being refined; each is a jewel of a resource for Buddhists
* [[Poverty]]
** largely written by Martin Wyatt
** nominated by Pat Palmer
** could use polish and fleshing out, but a gem as it stands
** submitted to Encyclosphere via ZWI Export on 3/23/2022 [[User:Pat Palmer|Pat Palmer]] ([[User talk:Pat Palmer|talk]]) 14:06, 24 March 2022 (CDT)
* [[Roman alphabet]]
** written by Domergue Sumien
** nominated by Pat Palmer
* [[Scientific method]]
** nominated by Gareth Leng
** nominated by Gareth Leng
* [[Shortest path routing]]
** largely written by David MacQuigg
** nominated by Pat Palmer


== Self nominated ==
== List of articles nominated by the article's lead ==


* [[Amaryllis]]
** written by Pat Palmer
** nominated by Pat Palmer
** its Wikipedia equivalent has much more detail but is jargon-filled and doesn't tell a normal person the essential information succinctly
** submitted to Encyclosphere via ZWI Export on 3/23/2022 [[User:Pat Palmer|Pat Palmer]] ([[User talk:Pat Palmer|talk]]) 12:25, 24 March 2022 (CDT)
* [[Battle Abbey]]
* [[Battle Abbey]]
** nominated by Richard Nevell, 8/13/2020
** nominated by Richard Nevell, 8/13/2020
** largely written by Richard Nevell
** largely written by Richard Nevell
** The differences with Wikipedia aren't as obvious as they used to be, but can go toe to toe with WP versions. Comparable in length, if not more detailed than WP, and referenced throughout.
** The differences with Wikipedia aren't as obvious as they used to be, but can go toe to toe with WP versions. Comparable in length, if not more detailed than WP, and referenced throughout.
* [[Calypso (card game)]]
** nominated by Peter Jackson
** written by Peter Jackson
** no WP article
* [[Civil society]]
* [[Civil society]]
** nominated by Roger Lohmann (no relation), 8/13/2020
** nominated by Roger Lohmann, 8/13/2020
** largely written by Roger Lohmann
** largely written by Roger Lohmann
** Nominated in part because it makes the most extensive use possible of subpages.
** Nominated in part because it makes the most extensive use possible of subpages.
* [[Collected editions of Shakespeare]]
** nominated by Peter Jackson
** mainly written by Peter Jackson
** only brief article [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complete_Works_of_Shakespeare] on WP
* [[Cowdray House]]
* [[Cowdray House]]
** nominated by Richard Nevell, 8/13/2020
** nominated by Richard Nevell, 8/13/2020
Line 72: Line 135:
** largely written by Richard Nevell
** largely written by Richard Nevell
** The differences with Wikipedia aren't as obvious as they used to be, but can go toe to toe with WP versions. Comparable in length, if not more detailed than WP, and referenced throughout.
** The differences with Wikipedia aren't as obvious as they used to be, but can go toe to toe with WP versions. Comparable in length, if not more detailed than WP, and referenced throughout.
* [[Mary Baker Eddy]]
** nominated by Pat Palmer, 9/23/2020
** largely written by Pat Palmer
** it distills what I've found interesting about Mrs. Eddy, and focuses on two biographies about her[[User:Pat Palmer|Pat Palmer]] ([[User talk:Pat Palmer|talk]]) 01:40, 24 September 2020 (UTC)
** this overview of her is more balanced and succinct than most of what can be found anywhere on the web
* [[L. J. Hanifan]] - American educator
* [[L. J. Hanifan]] - American educator
** nominated by Roger Lohmann, 8/13/2020
** nominated by Roger Lohmann, 8/13/2020
** largely written by Roger Lohmann
** largely written by Roger Lohmann
**  It's not only good enough for Wikipedia. As comparison of publication and editing dates will clearly show, it was taken over in its entirety and published at Wikipedia, with some very minor revisions.
**  It's not only good enough for Wikipedia. As comparison of publication and editing dates will clearly show, it was taken over in its entirety and published at Wikipedia, with some very minor revisions.
* [[Michael Gilbert]]
** nominated by Hayford Peirce
** largely written by Hayford Peirce
** As of August 2020, Hayford thinks this is clearly superior to the WP https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Gilbert
** He also says: "All of the articles I wrote originally for CZ have been ported over to WP and exist there in one form or another.  As the years have gone by, the WP "vandals and cretins" have done less work on destroying them than they used to.  But SOME of my articles, which I originally wrote a long time ago at WP and then ported to CZ because of the vandalism at WP, have been expanded and then re-ported to WP.  There they have been subject to various kinds of editing, not all of it, my my opinion, for the best. Their merits could, of course, be argued, but basically WP takes out (or at least CERTAIN editors take out) whatever THEY think is POV or "non-encyl." etc -- I used to argue with them, now I no longer bother.  In any case, a lot of MY CZ articles are LONGER than the WP ones."
* [[Pompeii]]
* [[Pompeii]]
** nominated by Richard Nevell, 8/13/2020
** nominated by Richard Nevell, 8/13/2020
** largely written by Richard Nevell
** largely written by Richard Nevell
** The differences with Wikipedia aren't as obvious as they used to be, but can go toe to toe with WP versions. Comparable in length, if not more detailed than WP, and referenced throughout.
** The differences with Wikipedia aren't as obvious as they used to be, but can go toe to toe with WP versions. Comparable in length, if not more detailed than WP, and referenced throughout.
* [[Quinto (card game)]]
** nominated by Peter Jackson
** written by Peter Jackson
** no WP article
* [[Quinto (grid game)]]
** written by Pat Palmer
** nominated by Pat Palmer
** no WP article
** submitted to Encyclosphere via ZWI Export on 3/23/2022 [[User:Pat Palmer|Pat Palmer]] ([[User talk:Pat Palmer|talk]]) 12:26, 24 March 2022 (CDT)
* [[Theodor Lohmann]] - German social policy activist
* [[Theodor Lohmann]] - German social policy activist
** nominated by Roger Lohmann (no relation), 8/13/2020
** nominated by Roger Lohmann (no relation), 8/13/2020
Line 94: Line 166:
** now needs to be remained “Tony Blair, the premiership years” or something similar
** now needs to be remained “Tony Blair, the premiership years” or something similar
** What is unique about this is that (in defiance I have to say of Larry Sanger’s strictures) is that it was built around verbatim quotations. I worked hard to make this neutral, and I think I succeeded reasonably well in this from the comments I received.
** What is unique about this is that (in defiance I have to say of Larry Sanger’s strictures) is that it was built around verbatim quotations. I worked hard to make this neutral, and I think I succeeded reasonably well in this from the comments I received.
* [[Walt Whitman]]
** nominated by Pat Palmer, 9/23/2020
** largely written by Pat Palmer
** it distills what I've found interesting about Whitman: his literary opus, and his importance in contemporary culture
** doesn't even attempt to cover his life in any detail, since thousands of people on the web are obsessing about that

Latest revision as of 00:43, 9 February 2024


Below are articles which have been nominated as ready for reading. These may be featured on the landing page or in advertisements for new members.

We particularly want examples of articles that are different from what one would expect to find on Wikipedia in some important way. Communal editing by the larger crew of authors in Wikipedia can often end up degrading a good article, because while it may result in an increase in accuracy details, it may disrupt the voice and global structure of the article, as well as its clarity and focus on fundamentals. It's the difference, for example, between a chapter in a textbook that will delight a student trying to learn a difficult subject, and the usual pile of overwhelming detail. In this respect, the Citizendium's smaller pool of active authors makes for a more productive writing environment than is possible in a larger wiki.

Many of these articles have been ported already to Wikipedia, where they can enjoy a wider exposure and are guaranteed to persist longer. However, in some cases, the Wikipedia versions have since been extensively modified, and not always in ways that improve the article.

Several members of the Advisory group (as of August 2020) like the idea of having multiple articles by different authors on the same topic. In some cases, they challenge people to better their own self-nominated articles below.

We don't necessarily consider the following articles polished, perfect or complete, but we believe that their existence is a valuable addition to articles about the same topics in other online encyclopedias.

How to add a nomination

To nominate an article, please add it in alphabetical order to one of the two lists below. Using the list format we've begun here, please add it to the appropriate list, including sublist items for who the lead author was (if known), who is making the nomination, and any comments helping to explain its value.

List of articles nominated by non-leads

  • Acid rain
    • mostly the work of Milton Beychok back in 2010
    • nominated by Pat Palmer
  • American conservatism
    • nominated by Roger Lohmann, 8/13/2020
    • largely written by Howard Berkowitz
    • also some related national security topics by HB – although controversial with some – really very, very good. Milton Boychek was also a very active contributor at about that same time.
    • submitted to Encyclosphere via ZWI Export on 3/23/2022 Pat Palmer (talk) 12:21, 24 March 2022 (CDT)
  • Benchmark quantities
    • largely written by Mark Widmer
    • imaginative and absolutely unique; I haven't seen anything like it anywhere; and, it has some laughs buried in it
  • Bottle
    • nominated by Pat Palmer
    • needs a few graphics/photos
    • charming and sweet
    • collaboratively written, with contribs from Ro, Larry, Gareth and Tom Morris
  • Coal_mining
    • written in part by User:Pat_Palmer, as well as several others
    • submitted to Encyclosphere via ZWI Export on 3/23/2022 Pat Palmer (talk) 12:32, 24 March 2022 (CDT)
  • COVID-19
    • largely written by Gareth Leng
    • nominated by Pat Palmer
    • neutral introduction and overview of the current pandemic
    • submitted to Encyclosphere via ZWI Export on 3/23/2022 Pat Palmer (talk) 12:23, 24 March 2022 (CDT)
  • Dark Peak
    • largely written by User:Martin_Wyatt
    • nominated by Pat Palmer
    • far better (at present) than its WP counterpart
    • submitted to Encyclosphere via ZWI Export on 3/23/2022 Pat Palmer (talk) 12:23, 24 March 2022 (CDT)
  • Football to 1900
    • nominated by Roger Lohmann
    • largely written by John Leach
  • Jane_Addams - American social worker, author, pacifist and feminist leader and Nobel Peace Prize laureate, the first American woman so honored
    • nominated by Roger Lohmann, 8/13/2020
    • largely written by Richard Jensen
    • Truly outstanding; appears to have been ported to Wikipedia very recently
  • Life
    • nominated by Gareth Leng
    • lead author Anthony Sebastian
    • This was Anthony’s tour-de-force; idiosyncratic in places, yet with a unity of tone and intent that is striking.
  • Line (Euclidean geometry)
    • nominated by Gareth Leng
    • did not compare to the WP version
  • One-way_encryption, a.k.a. Password_encryption
    • nominated by Pat Palmer (and mostly written by me)
    • All this and much more in Wikipedia, but if you want to know how computers store and use passwords, this is what you need
  • Neighborhood (social science)
    • nominated by Gareth Leng
    • largely written by Roger Lohmann
    • did not compare to the WP version
    • Featured Article on landing page, 8/28/2020
  • Pali, Pali Canon and Pali Text Society
    • largely written by Peter Jackson
    • nominated by Pat Palmer
    • still being refined; each is a jewel of a resource for Buddhists
  • Poverty
    • largely written by Martin Wyatt
    • nominated by Pat Palmer
    • could use polish and fleshing out, but a gem as it stands
    • submitted to Encyclosphere via ZWI Export on 3/23/2022 Pat Palmer (talk) 14:06, 24 March 2022 (CDT)
  • Roman alphabet
    • written by Domergue Sumien
    • nominated by Pat Palmer
  • Scientific method
    • nominated by Gareth Leng
  • Shortest path routing
    • largely written by David MacQuigg
    • nominated by Pat Palmer

List of articles nominated by the article's lead

  • Amaryllis
    • written by Pat Palmer
    • nominated by Pat Palmer
    • its Wikipedia equivalent has much more detail but is jargon-filled and doesn't tell a normal person the essential information succinctly
    • submitted to Encyclosphere via ZWI Export on 3/23/2022 Pat Palmer (talk) 12:25, 24 March 2022 (CDT)
  • Battle Abbey
    • nominated by Richard Nevell, 8/13/2020
    • largely written by Richard Nevell
    • The differences with Wikipedia aren't as obvious as they used to be, but can go toe to toe with WP versions. Comparable in length, if not more detailed than WP, and referenced throughout.
  • Calypso (card game)
    • nominated by Peter Jackson
    • written by Peter Jackson
    • no WP article
  • Civil society
    • nominated by Roger Lohmann, 8/13/2020
    • largely written by Roger Lohmann
    • Nominated in part because it makes the most extensive use possible of subpages.
  • Collected editions of Shakespeare
    • nominated by Peter Jackson
    • mainly written by Peter Jackson
    • only brief article [1] on WP
  • Cowdray House
    • nominated by Richard Nevell, 8/13/2020
    • The differences with Wikipedia aren't as obvious as they used to be, but can go toe to toe with WP versions. Comparable in length, if not more detailed than WP, and referenced throughout.
  • Edinburgh
    • nominated by Gareth Leng, 8/13/2020
    • largely written by Gareth Leng
    • This was distinctly a labour of affection, full of personal asides and jokes. It was in my eyes, my attempt to render a modern day equivalent of Robert Louis Stevenson’s “Picturesque notes on Edinburgh”
  • Email system
    • nominated by David MacQuigg (8/13/2020)
    • largely written by David MacQuigg
    • This was written after great frustration in reading chapters in all the standard textbooks on computer networks. It presents a unique and very useful view that would quickly be shredded if it were on WP. I like the idea of having multiple articles by different authors on the same topic. I challenge anyone to provide a better explanation of email systems.
    • This particular article is being covered up in searches by the article entitled simply Email
  • Hopton Castle
    • nominated by Richard Nevell, 8/13/2020
    • largely written by Richard Nevell
    • The differences with Wikipedia aren't as obvious as they used to be, but can go toe to toe with WP versions. Comparable in length, if not more detailed than WP, and referenced throughout.
  • Lindisfarne Priory
    • nominated by Richard Nevell, 8/13/2020
    • largely written by Richard Nevell
    • Richard thinks it doesn't have an article on the English Wikipedia
  • Malbork Castle
    • nominated by Richard Nevell, 8/13/2020
    • largely written by Richard Nevell
    • The differences with Wikipedia aren't as obvious as they used to be, but can go toe to toe with WP versions. Comparable in length, if not more detailed than WP, and referenced throughout.
  • Mary Baker Eddy
    • nominated by Pat Palmer, 9/23/2020
    • largely written by Pat Palmer
    • it distills what I've found interesting about Mrs. Eddy, and focuses on two biographies about herPat Palmer (talk) 01:40, 24 September 2020 (UTC)
    • this overview of her is more balanced and succinct than most of what can be found anywhere on the web
  • L. J. Hanifan - American educator
    • nominated by Roger Lohmann, 8/13/2020
    • largely written by Roger Lohmann
    • It's not only good enough for Wikipedia. As comparison of publication and editing dates will clearly show, it was taken over in its entirety and published at Wikipedia, with some very minor revisions.
  • Pompeii
    • nominated by Richard Nevell, 8/13/2020
    • largely written by Richard Nevell
    • The differences with Wikipedia aren't as obvious as they used to be, but can go toe to toe with WP versions. Comparable in length, if not more detailed than WP, and referenced throughout.
  • Quinto (card game)
    • nominated by Peter Jackson
    • written by Peter Jackson
    • no WP article
  • Quinto (grid game)
    • written by Pat Palmer
    • nominated by Pat Palmer
    • no WP article
    • submitted to Encyclosphere via ZWI Export on 3/23/2022 Pat Palmer (talk) 12:26, 24 March 2022 (CDT)
  • Theodor Lohmann - German social policy activist
    • nominated by Roger Lohmann (no relation), 8/13/2020
    • largely written by Roger Lohmann
    • It's not only good enough for Wikipedia. As comparison of publication and editing dates will clearly show, it was taken over in its entirety and published at Wikipedia, with some very minor revisions.
  • Tony Blair
    • nominated by Gareth Leng, 8/13/2020
    • largely written by Gareth Leng
    • now needs to be remained “Tony Blair, the premiership years” or something similar
    • What is unique about this is that (in defiance I have to say of Larry Sanger’s strictures) is that it was built around verbatim quotations. I worked hard to make this neutral, and I think I succeeded reasonably well in this from the comments I received.
  • Walt Whitman
    • nominated by Pat Palmer, 9/23/2020
    • largely written by Pat Palmer
    • it distills what I've found interesting about Whitman: his literary opus, and his importance in contemporary culture
    • doesn't even attempt to cover his life in any detail, since thousands of people on the web are obsessing about that
Retrieved from "https://citizendium.org/wiki/index.php?title=CZ:Ready_for_reading&oldid=916324"