Indranee Rajah: Difference between revisions
(Created page with "{{subpages}} <!-- Please ignore (but don't delete) any formatting that you are not familiar with. Others will probably chime in to help you set things up. --> Indranee Rajah is a PAP member, and one of the MP representing Tanjong Pagar GRC at the time. ==Footnotes== {{reflist|2}} <!--We don't add Wikipedia-like 'categories' (e.g. 'Category:History') to the text of articles at Citizendium because these are automatically added by the softwa...") |
No edit summary |
||
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{subpages}} | {{subpages}} | ||
<!-- Please ignore (but don't delete) any formatting that you are not familiar with. Others will probably chime in to help you set things up. --> | <!-- Please ignore (but don't delete) any formatting that you are not familiar with. Others will probably chime in to help you set things up. --> | ||
{{Infobox Person | |||
| name = Indranee Rajah | |||
| portrait = Indranee_Rajah_(4x5).jpg | |||
| other_names = இந்திராணி ராஜா | |||
| website = | |||
| birth_date = 1963 | |||
| birth_place = State of Singapore | |||
| death_date = | |||
| death_place = | |||
| occupation = Politician | |||
| title = | |||
| salary = | |||
| term = | |||
| predecessor = | |||
| successor = | |||
| party = [[People's Action Party]] | |||
| boards = | |||
| religion = | |||
| relations = | |||
| footnotes = | |||
}} | |||
Indranee Rajah is a [[People's Action Party|PAP]] member, and one of the MP representing Tanjong Pagar GRC at the time. | Indranee Rajah is a [[People's Action Party|PAP]] member, and one of the MP representing Tanjong Pagar GRC at the time. | ||
==Controversy== | |||
===Indranee Rajah on the cost of living in Singapore=== | |||
{{quotation|People respond to cost of living in terms of how does it impact on them. What is their lived experience like. How can they manage their household budgets. So we do understand, we do understand. | |||
And I think what PM was doing yesterday was to really explain some of the reasons why some of the costs have gone up, some things are unavoidable. You look at our electricity prices for example. That’s tied obviously to the price of oil that we buy, so that goes up and down. | |||
But the question is how can you alleviate that. You do that through the U-Save and the subsidies right? So Government can do its part by providing the options like now introducing more polyclinics, as you’ve pointed out, and also introducing more hawker centres. | |||
But its’ also about choices. Because if there are 2 or 3 different things, is it always necessary to choose the most expensive one? Possibly not. | |||
Because so long as the lower cost option does provide you with what you need – and Prime Minister cited milk powder for example, it’s a good example of that. And the problem is also exacerbated by the fact that you have the companies who sell things, which also make representations about it – again in the milk powder context right. | |||
So we want to be able to make sure that firstly, there are options that people have options to buy the different things at the different prices. And the other important thing is to also make sure that you have the information available so that people can make the right choices. | |||
And where something is where the cost is relatively high, you provide assistance with it. So take housing, for example: Housing for young families is subsidised, especially for the first-timers. It’s a big cost item but the Government will do its part and put in the subsidy. | |||
But also for the person who is buying, think about whether it should be really a 5-room or a 4-room or a 3-room – whatever it is that is right for your budget. | |||
If you look at preschool, we are putting in more options. Also, we’ve heavily subsidised the childcare, for example. | |||
So it takes two. The Government will do its part – that is our commitment. We want to make sure that Singaporeans are able to manage their cost of living, their daily expenses. But at the same time, we hope that people will also think through what they are able to afford and manage and also to make the right choices | |||
|Indranee Rajah|August 2018}} | |||
In August 2018, Indranee was interviewed by CNA938 radio station about the cost of living in Singapore.<ref>https://www.facebook.com/ChannelNewsAsia/videos/1948188671900624/</ref> After the interview, she was criticised by the public for her "patronising" comments, especially of her mentioning "think through what they are able to afford".<ref>https://theindependent.sg/stop-patronising-us-hundreds-slam-indranee-rajah-for-saying-singaporeans-should-think-through-what-they-are-able-to-afford/</ref><ref>https://theindependent.sg/you-cant-blame-the-people-for-getting-upset-when-highly-paid-ministers-tell-them-to-think-through-how-to-manage-their-expenses/</ref> | |||
===Slamming file in parliament=== | |||
In March 2023 parliament session, after Progress Singapore Party NCMP Leong Mun Wai said, "speaker, if the minister didn’t ask me, I suggest you don’t ask", Indranee immediately slams her file, raising her hand to get the other MP's attention, and went to the podium, she gave a talk to "emind members to conduct themselves in a parliamentary manner and the tone which we address one another is important" and "asked" Leong to be mindful.<ref>https://gutzy.asia/2023/11/27/leader-of-house-indranee-rajah-warns-leong-mun-wai-for-conduct-during-parliamentary-exchange-but-not-minister-shanmugam-for-using-coward-against-him/</ref><ref>https://coconuts.co/singapore/news/politician-leong-mun-wai-apologizes-after-heated-words-during-tense-debate-in-parliament-video-shanmugam/</ref> | |||
==Footnotes== | ==Footnotes== |
Latest revision as of 05:41, 9 March 2024
Indranee Rajah | |
---|---|
Other names | இந்திராணி ராஜா |
Born | 1963 State of Singapore |
Occupation | Politician |
Political party | People's Action Party |
Indranee Rajah is a PAP member, and one of the MP representing Tanjong Pagar GRC at the time.
Controversy
Indranee Rajah on the cost of living in Singapore
People respond to cost of living in terms of how does it impact on them. What is their lived experience like. How can they manage their household budgets. So we do understand, we do understand.
And I think what PM was doing yesterday was to really explain some of the reasons why some of the costs have gone up, some things are unavoidable. You look at our electricity prices for example. That’s tied obviously to the price of oil that we buy, so that goes up and down. But the question is how can you alleviate that. You do that through the U-Save and the subsidies right? So Government can do its part by providing the options like now introducing more polyclinics, as you’ve pointed out, and also introducing more hawker centres. But its’ also about choices. Because if there are 2 or 3 different things, is it always necessary to choose the most expensive one? Possibly not. Because so long as the lower cost option does provide you with what you need – and Prime Minister cited milk powder for example, it’s a good example of that. And the problem is also exacerbated by the fact that you have the companies who sell things, which also make representations about it – again in the milk powder context right. So we want to be able to make sure that firstly, there are options that people have options to buy the different things at the different prices. And the other important thing is to also make sure that you have the information available so that people can make the right choices. And where something is where the cost is relatively high, you provide assistance with it. So take housing, for example: Housing for young families is subsidised, especially for the first-timers. It’s a big cost item but the Government will do its part and put in the subsidy. But also for the person who is buying, think about whether it should be really a 5-room or a 4-room or a 3-room – whatever it is that is right for your budget. If you look at preschool, we are putting in more options. Also, we’ve heavily subsidised the childcare, for example. So it takes two. The Government will do its part – that is our commitment. We want to make sure that Singaporeans are able to manage their cost of living, their daily expenses. But at the same time, we hope that people will also think through what they are able to afford and manage and also to make the right choices
— Indranee Rajah, August 2018
In August 2018, Indranee was interviewed by CNA938 radio station about the cost of living in Singapore.[1] After the interview, she was criticised by the public for her "patronising" comments, especially of her mentioning "think through what they are able to afford".[2][3]
Slamming file in parliament
In March 2023 parliament session, after Progress Singapore Party NCMP Leong Mun Wai said, "speaker, if the minister didn’t ask me, I suggest you don’t ask", Indranee immediately slams her file, raising her hand to get the other MP's attention, and went to the podium, she gave a talk to "emind members to conduct themselves in a parliamentary manner and the tone which we address one another is important" and "asked" Leong to be mindful.[4][5]
Footnotes
- ↑ https://www.facebook.com/ChannelNewsAsia/videos/1948188671900624/
- ↑ https://theindependent.sg/stop-patronising-us-hundreds-slam-indranee-rajah-for-saying-singaporeans-should-think-through-what-they-are-able-to-afford/
- ↑ https://theindependent.sg/you-cant-blame-the-people-for-getting-upset-when-highly-paid-ministers-tell-them-to-think-through-how-to-manage-their-expenses/
- ↑ https://gutzy.asia/2023/11/27/leader-of-house-indranee-rajah-warns-leong-mun-wai-for-conduct-during-parliamentary-exchange-but-not-minister-shanmugam-for-using-coward-against-him/
- ↑ https://coconuts.co/singapore/news/politician-leong-mun-wai-apologizes-after-heated-words-during-tense-debate-in-parliament-video-shanmugam/