Talk:Political spectrum: Difference between revisions
imported>Tom Morris (New page: {{subpages}}) |
imported>Tom Morris No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{subpages}} | {{subpages}} | ||
== Imported from Requested Articles == | |||
''Now that the article exists, I thought it might be sensible to move the comments over from [[CZ:Requested Articles]] so that the comments don't clutter up [[CZ:Fulfilled Article Requests]] forever more. –[[User:Tom Morris|Tom Morris]] 19:33, 11 November 2009 (UTC)'' | |||
Besides giving examples of other spectrums out there, I propose that we order political beliefs into a three-axis table based on the following properties: economic freedom, political freedom, and social freedom. I'd also like to see tables where variants of the same belief are compared to each other. –[[User:Matthew Woods]] | |||
Response from [[User:Bruce M. Tindall|Bruce M. Tindall]] 18:06, 21 November 2007 (CST): Ah, but it might be difficult to do so in an objective way. One person's "high degree of economic freedom" is another person's "low degree of social justice"; "high social freedom" might be described as "low social order" or "low public safety" by someone else. The choice and naming of the axes for such a scheme right away implies a system and hierarchy of values. There's also the question of which axes are left out: is there a dimension for measuring, say, the relative powers or duties belonging to different groupings of people (individuals, families, "races," nation-states and their political subdivisions, genders, voluntary organizations, etc.)? After all, in the U.S., the 50 states have considerable sovereignty in certain areas; in other countries, power is more centralized; so there's yet another dimension of the political spectrum (probably not describable as any kind of "freedom") right there. | |||
Revision as of 14:33, 11 November 2009
Imported from Requested Articles
Now that the article exists, I thought it might be sensible to move the comments over from CZ:Requested Articles so that the comments don't clutter up CZ:Fulfilled Article Requests forever more. –Tom Morris 19:33, 11 November 2009 (UTC)
Besides giving examples of other spectrums out there, I propose that we order political beliefs into a three-axis table based on the following properties: economic freedom, political freedom, and social freedom. I'd also like to see tables where variants of the same belief are compared to each other. –User:Matthew Woods
Response from Bruce M. Tindall 18:06, 21 November 2007 (CST): Ah, but it might be difficult to do so in an objective way. One person's "high degree of economic freedom" is another person's "low degree of social justice"; "high social freedom" might be described as "low social order" or "low public safety" by someone else. The choice and naming of the axes for such a scheme right away implies a system and hierarchy of values. There's also the question of which axes are left out: is there a dimension for measuring, say, the relative powers or duties belonging to different groupings of people (individuals, families, "races," nation-states and their political subdivisions, genders, voluntary organizations, etc.)? After all, in the U.S., the 50 states have considerable sovereignty in certain areas; in other countries, power is more centralized; so there's yet another dimension of the political spectrum (probably not describable as any kind of "freedom") right there.