Arab Spring/Addendum: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Nick Gardner
imported>Nick Gardner
Line 77: Line 77:
===[[Yemen]]===
===[[Yemen]]===
''([PEE],Population 24m, 99% Muslim, CPI 2010: 2.2, DI 2010: 2.6, unemployment rate: 35%, GDP/head: $2,700)''<br>
''([PEE],Population 24m, 99% Muslim, CPI 2010: 2.2, DI 2010: 2.6, unemployment rate: 35%, GDP/head: $2,700)''<br>
The Yemeni uprising took the form of peaceful protests about unemployment, malnutrion and corruption, but were violently repulsed by the country's armed forces. On 18 March 2011, 53 persons were reportedly killed in demonstration, an incident which lead to the resignation of a number of Ministers, Ambassadors and other members of the ruling party, and the defection of General Ali Mohsen Al-Ahmar who vowed to send  his  20,000-strong First Armoured Brigade troops to protect the peaceful demonstrators. A bitter power struggle developed between the president's clan and their rivals, the Bani al-Ahmar<ref>[http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-14080126 Frank Gardner: ''Arab Spring: Where it is now and where it may be going'', BBC News 10 July 2011]</ref>. Riots continued after President Saleh promised to step down in 2013, and in August 2011, he said  that Yemenis were "committed" to various initiatives proposed by Gulf states and members of the Security Council to "as soon as possible … arrange to hold general and free and direct elections for the new president of the country,"[http://www.upi.com/Top_News/Special/2011/08/30/Yemens-Saleh-backing-down/UPI-56931314716025/#ixzz1WXdIz6kg]. In September 2011, a United Nations mission reported that protesters were trying to preserve the peaceful character of their demonstrations, but were being met with "the excessive use of lethal force". The mission considered that the growing activity of "armed elements" among the demonstrators presented the danger of a  cycle of escalating violence<ref>[http://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Countries/YE/YemenAssessmentMissionReport.pdf ''Report of the High Commissioner on OHCHR’s visit to Yemen'', United Nations Human Rights Council, Eighteenth session 13 September 2011]</ref>.
The Yemeni uprising in January 2011  took the form of peaceful protests about unemployment, malnutrion and corruption, but it was violently repulsed by the country's armed forces, and hundreds were killed. A bitter power struggle also developed between the president's clan and their rivals, the Bani al-Ahmar<ref>[http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-14080126 Frank Gardner: ''Arab Spring: Where it is now and where it may be going'', BBC News 10 July 2011]</ref>. An incident in March, when  53 peaceful demonstrators were killed, led to the resignation of a number of Ministers, Ambassadors and other members of the ruling party, and the defection of General Ali Mohsen Al-Ahmar, with a promise to his armoured brigade troops to protect the demonstrators.  In August 2011, President Saleh promised to step down in 2013, and to hold free and direct elections[http://www.upi.com/Top_News/Special/2011/08/30/Yemens-Saleh-backing-down/UPI-56931314716025/#ixzz1WXdIz6kg],but the demonstrations continued. In September 2011, a United Nations mission reported that protesters were trying to preserve the peaceful character of their demonstrations, but were being met with the excessive and disproportionate use of lethal force. The mission considered that the growing activity of "armed elements" among the demonstrators presented the danger of a  cycle of escalating violence<ref>[http://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Countries/YE/YemenAssessmentMissionReport.pdf ''Report of the High Commissioner on OHCHR’s visit to Yemen'', United Nations Human Rights Council, Eighteenth session 13 September 2011]</ref>.


==The international response==
==The international response==

Revision as of 15:26, 30 September 2011

This article is developed but not approved.
Main Article
Discussion
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
Catalogs [?]
Timelines [?]
Addendum [?]
 
This addendum is a continuation of the article Arab Spring.

Key
[OE] denotes oil economy
[MOE] denotes mixed oil economy
[DE] denotes diversified economy
[PEE] denotes primary exporting economy
CPI denotes the Corruption Protection Index[1], which ranges from 0 for highly corrupt to 10 for totally transparent.
DI denotes Democracy Index [2] which ranges from 0 for totalitarian to 10 for fully democratic.
GI denotes Gini index which is a number between 0 and 100 reflecting the degree of inequality of family income[3].
GDP/head figures are at purchasing power parity exchange rates using CIA World Factbook figures[4].


Notes are available on the persona mentioned below.


Arab national movements

(Situation on 1 August 2011}

Algeria

([MOE], Population 35m, 99% Sunni Muslim CPI 2010: 2.9, DI 2010: 3.4, unemployment rate: 9.9%, GDP/head: $7,300), OPEC member country profile
The protests and strikes in January and after were mainly about living standards and corruption. President Bouteflika responded with cuts in food prices, and a promise to review the constitution. Algeria does not recognise the Libyan National Transitional Council.

Bahrain

([OE], Population 1.2 m, 81% Muslim, CPI 2010: 4.9, DI 2010: 3.5, unemployment rate: 3.6%, GDP/head: $40,300)
Protest movements have been crushed by force, increasing the previously existing tensions between the Shi'ite majority and the Sunni minority[5].

Egypt

([DE], Population 82m, 90% Muslim, CPI 2010: 3.1, DI 2010: 3.1,unemployment rate: 9.7%, GDP/head: $6,200)
In February 2011, mass protests ended the 30-year presidency of Hosni Mubarak, and he was replaced by the "Supreme Council of the Armed Forces" (SCAF)[6] that has promised a transition to democracy [7]. Protests continued as a result of tension between the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces and the youth movements that launched the January 25th Tahrir Square uprising [8], and in July there was a mass demonstration, organised by the Islamist Muslim Brotherhood, calling for an Islamic state and Sharia law[9].

Jordan

([DE], Population 6.5m, 92% Muslim, CPI 2010:4.7, DI 2010: 3.7, GI: 38, unemployment rate: 13.4%, GDP/head: $5,400)
King Abdullah responded to the mainly peaceful protests by sacking his Cabinet and appointing a new Prime Minister. There have since been few protests.

Lebanon

([DE], Population 4m, 60% Muslim, 39% Christian, CPI 2010: 2.5,DI 2010: 5.8, unemployment rate:9.2 %, GDP/head: $14,400)
The January protests were against Hezbollah's attempt to take over the country's government.

Libya

([MOE], Population 6.6m, 97% Muslim, CPI 2010: 2.3, DI 2010: 1.9, GI: 36, unemployment rate: 20.7%, GDP/head: $14,000), OPEC member

The protests developed into a major civil war with over 10,000 casualties, in which the rebels were supported with NATO supplies and airstrikes. Libya's complex tribal structure is said to play a crucial role in its politics and now in the pro-democracy opposition movement[10]. The rebel National Transitional Council has been recognised as the legitimate representative of the Libyan people by the USA, France and the UK.

Morocco

([DE], Population 40m, 99% Muslim, CPI 2010: 3.4, DI 2010: 3.8, unemployment rate:9.8%, GDP/head: $4,800)
Protests have been mainly peaceful. King Mohammed has promised constitutional reform.

Oman

([OE], Population 3m, 75% Muslim, CPI 2010: 5.3,DI 2010: 2.9, unemployment rate: 15%, GDP/head: $23,600)
The Sultan has responded to protests by promising to give legislative powers to Oman's parliament.

Saudi Arabia

([OE], Population 26m, 100% Muslim, CPI 2010: 4.7, DI 2010: 1.8, GI: 32, unemployment rate: 10.8%, GDP/head: $24,200), OPEC member
Protests have been few and local, confined to Shia areas in the east. The Saudi army was used to crush the opposition in Bahrain. In September 2011 the King announced that women are to be allowed to vote and to become members of the Advisory Council[11].

Syria

([DE], Population 23m, 90% Muslim, CPI 2010: 2.5, DI 2010: 2.3, unemployment rate: 8.3%, GDP/head: $4,800)
Syrian security forces have fired on unarmed protesters, possibly killing as many as 1,000 of them. President Bashir al-Assad has repealed an unpopular Emergency Law.[12]

Tunisia

([DE], Population 10.6m, 98% Muslim, CPI 2010: 4.3, DI 2010: 2.8,unemployment rate: 14%, GDP/head: $9,400)
Protesters have forced the resignation of President Zine al-Abidine Mebazaa, and elections have been scheduled for October 2011 after several delays. The outlawed Islamist party, Hizb al-Nahda, has been legalised. The head of the army, General Rachid Ben Ammar, has announced that the army intends to act as the "guarantor of the revolution".

Yemen

([PEE],Population 24m, 99% Muslim, CPI 2010: 2.2, DI 2010: 2.6, unemployment rate: 35%, GDP/head: $2,700)
The Yemeni uprising in January 2011 took the form of peaceful protests about unemployment, malnutrion and corruption, but it was violently repulsed by the country's armed forces, and hundreds were killed. A bitter power struggle also developed between the president's clan and their rivals, the Bani al-Ahmar[13]. An incident in March, when 53 peaceful demonstrators were killed, led to the resignation of a number of Ministers, Ambassadors and other members of the ruling party, and the defection of General Ali Mohsen Al-Ahmar, with a promise to his armoured brigade troops to protect the demonstrators. In August 2011, President Saleh promised to step down in 2013, and to hold free and direct elections[2],but the demonstrations continued. In September 2011, a United Nations mission reported that protesters were trying to preserve the peaceful character of their demonstrations, but were being met with the excessive and disproportionate use of lethal force. The mission considered that the growing activity of "armed elements" among the demonstrators presented the danger of a cycle of escalating violence[14].

The international response

The United Nations

On February 2011, the Security Council unanimously adopted resolution 1970 [15], imposing an arms embargo on Libya and freezing the assets of its leaders. On March 17, it adopted resolution 1973 (2011) by a vote of 10 in favour to none against, with 5 abstentions (Brazil, China, Germany, India, Russian Federation), authorising Member States, "to take all necessary measures to protect civilians under threat of attack in the country, including Benghazi, while excluding a foreign occupation force of any form on any part of Libyan territory" [16].

The European Union

The European Commission has made available EUR €30 million for humanitarian aid in Libya and to refugees at the Tunisian and Egyptian borders. The EU has also offered Arab Countries "Partnerships for Democracy and Shared Prosperity” conditinal upon evidence of concrete progress toward the establishment of democracy, human rights, social justice, good governance and the rule of law [17]. France and Britain have taken major parts in the NATO intervention in Libya which, however has been opposed by Italy [18] and Germany [19].

NATO

On March 27 2011, NATO decided to take on the whole military operation in Libya under United Nations Security Council Resolution 1973. The stated purpose of Operation Unified Protector was "to protect civilians and civilian-populated areas under threat of attack[20]." Of the its 28 members, 14 took military action in support of the uprising, 8[21] of which took part in ground attacks.

USA

On 17 May 2011, President Obama announced a new chapter in American diplomacy. In addition to the pursuit of existing policy objectives, such as countering terrorism, it would be be the policy of the United States to promote reform across the region, and to support transitions to democracy. But, noting that the people themselves who had launched the protest movements, he emphasised that it should be "the people themselves that must ultimately determine their outcome"[22]. A CNN/Opinion Research Poll indicated approval by a majority of Americans as well as opposition by a substantial minority[23].

Russia

On 7 March Russian foreign minister Serghei Lavrov stressed Moscow's opposition to military intervention in Libya: "we don't see how any form of external intervention could possibly solve the Libyan crisis, especially if it were military in nature. Libyans need to solve their own problems.[24]

References

  1. Corruption Perception :Index[1]
  2. The Democracy Index 2010, Economist Intelligence Unit
  3. Global Peace Index 2010
  4. Country Comparison, GDP per Capita (PPP), CIA World Factbook July 2011
  5. Popular Protests in North Africa and the Middle East (III): The Bahrain Revolt, International Crisis Group, 6 April 2011, MENA Report No. 105
  6. Who is in Egypt's High Military Council? , International Business Times, February 11, 2011
  7. Supreme Council of the Armed Forces Constitutional Declaration Carnegie Endowment, 2011
  8. Khaled Elgindy: Egypt’s Transition Six Months On: From Diversity to Divisiveness,The Brookings Institution, 1 September 2011
  9. Egypt uprising: Islamists lead Tahrir Square rally, BBC News, 28 July 2011
  10. Navigating Libya's tribal maze, Al Jazeera, 23 February 2011
  11. Saudi women given voting rights, Al Jazeera, 26 September 2011
  12. Juan Cole (23 April 2011), "Syrian Security fires on Protesters, Kills 90", Informed Comment
  13. Frank Gardner: Arab Spring: Where it is now and where it may be going, BBC News 10 July 2011
  14. Report of the High Commissioner on OHCHR’s visit to Yemen, United Nations Human Rights Council, Eighteenth session 13 September 2011
  15. Security Council imposes sanctions on Libyan authorities in bid to stem violent repression, UN News Centre, 26 February 2011
  16. Security Council Approves No Fly Zone over Libya
  17. A Partnership for Democracy and Shared Prosperity with the Southern Mediterranean, Joint Communication to The European Council, The European Parliament, The Council, The European Economic and Social Committee and The Committee of the Regions, European Commission, 8 March, 2011
  18. Italy opposes military intervention in Libya.Digital Journal, 16 March 2011
  19. Luke Harding: Germany won't send forces to Libya, foreign minister declares, Guardian, 17 March 2011
  20. NATO and Libya, NATO press office 10 July 2011
  21. France, the UK, the US, Belgium, Denmark, Norway, Italy and Canada
  22. Obama’s Mideast Speech, New York Times, May 19, 2011
  23. CNN/Opinion Research Poll – March 18-20 – Libya.
  24. Ljubica Vujadinovic: Moscow says “No” to foreign military intervention in Libya, ALLVOICES, 7 March 2011