Talk:File Transfer Protocol

Getting this fleshed out for the Internet article -Eric M Gearhart 18:57, 13 July 2008 (CDT)

Improvements needed

Unfortunately, FTP was developed for a very different environment, and also at a time when we knew much less about building, operating, and especially troubleshooting networks. Were I to pick a single adjective to describe FTP, "ugly" comes to mind. Given additional words, I think of "very, very ugly."

In lieu of euthanasia, let me put on my Computers Editor hat and suggest an outline. Do avoid talking about the *NIX ftp command, or FTP utility programs for operating systems, until the protocol is discussed thoroughly. If it's really important to mention the command very early, we need to disambiguate:

"ftp" needs to redirect to a disambiguation page:

• File transfer protocol [r]: Add brief definition or description
• Ftp command and utilities [r]: Add brief definition or description

Outline

Introduction: what problem does FTP (the protocol) solve? What are its basic capabilities?

Design problems (major reference: "Firewall-friendly FTP", http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc1579.html. The first two items create problems even without considering security, such as not being able to work through a basic network address translator

Embedded IP addresses and port numbers in the application layer protocol

Port redirection

Firewall incompatibilities and passive open

Fault tolerance and checkpointing, or lack thereof

Secure alternatives

(commands and utilities)